It would appear that HP is about to launch a full scale assault against Apple’s flagship notebook, the MacBook Pro 17-inch and no one seems to have noticed.
A few days ago i stumbled across the HP Envy 17-1011NR notebook on Amazon.com and was instantly smitten. At first glance it seemed to have all the regular high-performance boxes checked – a fast processor, lots of RAM, a fast hard disk, good graphics, a large screen and a Blu-ray drive. All this at a pretty decent price. But after digging a little deeper I started to notice little touches that seemed to sound familiar. Little touches like the Mini DisplayPort and multi-touch gesture touchpad. Where had I heard those terms before? Oh yes! In Apple MacBook Pro specs. Then I noticed the laser-etched aluminum chassis and it all became clear. I was looking at the makings of a MacBook killer. A system forged by Sauron himself in the fires of Mount Doom. One notebook to rule them all. HP’s Precious.
Here’s a comparison of the Envy 17-1011NR next to a comparably tricked out MacBook Pro 17 from the Apple online store. Note that this configuration of the Envy 17 is not yet released although it can be pre-ordered at Amazon.
| |
Apple MacBook Pro 17
 |
HP Envy 17-1011NR
 |
| CPU |
Core i7 2.66~3.33 GHz |
Core i7 1.6~2.8 GHz |
| Memory |
8 GB DDR3 1066 MHz |
8 GB DDR3 1333 MHz |
| Hard Disk |
500 GB 7200 rpm |
640 GB (2 x 320 GB 7200 rpm) |
| Optical Drive |
Slot-loading DVD-/+R/RW |
Slot-loading DVD-/+R/RW with Blu-ray ROM |
| Display |
17” 1920 x 1200 Full HD LED Backlit |
17.3” 1920 x 1080 Full HD LED Backlit |
| Graphics |
NVIDIA GeForce GT 330M with 512 MB GDDR3 |
ATI Radeon Mobility HD 5850 with 1 GB GDDR5 |
| Video Out |
Mini DisplayPort (Supports VGA or DVI or HDMI via adapters) |
Mini DisplayPort and HDMI (Supports DVI via adapter) and VGA simultaneously via ATI EyeFinity |
| Audio |
Speakers with subwoofers Omni-directional mic Audio In Jack Audio Out Jack Supports iPhone headset with mic |
Beats Audio and HP Triple Bass Reflex Subwoofer Dual noise cancelling mics Audio In/Out Jack Supports 4-pin headset with mic |
| Keyboard |
Full Size Backlit |
Full Size Backlit |
| Pointing Device |
Multi-Touch Trackpad |
HP ClickPad with Multi-touch Gestures |
| Connectivity |
Wireless-A/B/G/N Bluetooth Gigabit Ethernet |
Wireless-A/B/G/N Bluetooth Gigabit Ethernet |
| Webcam |
iSight Camera |
HP TrueVision HD (1280 x 800) |
| Expansion |
1 x FireWire 800 3 x USB 2.0 SD Card Slot ExpressCard/34 Slot |
1 x Superspeed USB 3.0 3 x USB 2.0 (1 shared with eSATA) SD, MMC, MS, MS Pro, xD Card Slot eSATA |
| Chassis |
Aluminum Unibody |
Laser-etched Aluminum Finish in Carbon Relic |
| Weight |
6.6 lbs |
7.5 lbs |
| Price |
$2,949.00 (July 4, 2010 Apple.com) |
$1,649 (July 4, 2010 Amazon.com) $1,300 LESS!!! |
You’ll notice that the HP machine matches or beats the Apple in almost every component. And yes, you read correctly. It’s $1,300 cheaper. Note the killer points – Faster memory, larger hard drive, Blu-ray drive, larger 16×9 display, support for 3 external displays simultaneously, USB 3.0, External SATA, and support for more flash memory types. With all this you give up a FireWire800 port, ExpressCard slot, a slightly faster processor and you gain a pound.
What’s the verdict? Considering the big picture, I can live with the slower processor. It’s a Core i7 and that means 8-way multiprocessing. A few MHz won’t be missed, especially with the faster RAM in the HP. FireWire 800 seems to be only good for connecting to external hard drives. I’ve never come across another type of device that uses it and I’ve never come across the ports on any systems but Apple’s. USB 3.0 makes up for the missing FireWire 800 port and external drives that use the new USB standard have already hit the market.
The only true loss is the ExpressCard/34 slot which means that adding new types of device or expansion ports to the Envy won’t be possible unless they’re USB 2.0 or 3.0 compatible. For some that may be a deal-breaker but it’s not for me and it won’t be for the majority of users. One other thing to note about the Envy is the absence of a FireWire 400 port. Unlike it’s faster brother this type of port has been a staple on HPs performance notebooks for years as well as on systems from most vendors. Although you can connect external storage devices to an FireWire 400 port, the most common use is connecting to digital camcorders. Now that AVCHD camcorders that record to hard disks and SD cards have become the norm in the consumer and prosumer markets, this is less of a bother because USB ports and SD card slots offer the benefit of faster than real-time non-linear access to video stored on those cameras. But if you own an older HDV camcorder that records to tape, you only capture option is FireWire. And to make matters worse, the last of an ExpressCard slot means you can’t even add FireWire capability. This isn’t the end of the world. You can capture on another system then edit on your Envy. But that may not be an option for every user every time the need arises. And lastly, the MacBook Pro is about 1 lb lighter than the Envy. Again, this makes little difference when the price and other advantages of the Envy are taken into account.
It’s clear that the HP Envy 17-1011NR blows even the best Apple MacBook Pro 17 out of the water. I haven’t done a comparison of HP’s all-in-one desktops to the iMac, but HP has confirmed they’re working on a WebOS-based table now that their acquisition of Palm is complete. Such a device done right, and with the right amount of dedication to taking the wind out of Apple’s sails in the tablet dept. also could result in a simply brilliant product that hits the mark as precisely as the Envy. I wish HP all the best. May The Force be with them. Apple needs a reality check right about now.
Main HP Envy 17 series site.
Main Apple MacBook Pro site.

Loading ...